Year-End Tax Timing: Which Year Your Payments and Expenses Count
Your invoice date has no effect on your taxes. The day the money reaches you does. A $5,000 invoice you send on December 20 and that gets paid on January 6 belongs on next year's return, even though you finished the work this year.
Most solo freelancers use that rule, and it gives you a few weeks every November and December to decide which year some of your income and costs land in. This post shows where the lines are, what the IRS allows, and when moving things around is a waste of effort.
1.The Day the Money Lands Is the Day It Counts
Under the cash method of accounting, which IRS Publication 538 describes, you report income in the year you receive it and deduct costs in the year you pay them. The invoice date, the work date, and the due date don't matter.
One extra rule applies. The IRS calls it constructive receipt, which is a plain idea: money counts as yours once it's available to you with no strings, even if you haven't picked it up yet. Treasury Regulation 1.451-2 sets that rule. A check sitting in your mailbox on December 29 is this year's income, even if you don't deposit it until January 3.
2.Which Year a Late-December Payment Falls In
These are the cases that come up most around the new year. The pattern in each row is the same: ask when you could have spent the money.
| What happened | Counts in |
|---|---|
| Bank transfer lands in your account on Dec 30 | This year |
| Check arrives in your mailbox Dec 29, deposited Jan 3 | This year |
| Client mails a check Dec 28, it arrives Jan 4 | Next year |
| Invoice sent Dec 15, paid Jan 10 | Next year |
| Client pays a $2,000 deposit Dec 20 for work starting in January | This year |
The last row surprises people. A deposit is money you received, so it's income in the year it arrives, even if you haven't started the work.
Payment apps and card processors add a wrinkle. Money counts when it's available to you, so a payout that a processor holds until January 3 is a question for your tax preparer. The 1099-K form that a processor sends reports the payments it handled during the calendar year, which can differ from the dates on your bank deposits. Compare the form to your own records before you file.
3.Expenses Count When You Pay, Not When You Use Them
IRS Publication 535 says a cash-method business deducts an expense in the year it pays for it. A card charge counts on the day you swipe the card. If you buy a $900 monitor with your card on December 30 and pay the card bill in January, the deduction still belongs to this year.
You can also prepay some costs. A 12-month rule in the Treasury regulations (1.263(a)-4(f)) lets you deduct a prepaid cost in the year you pay if the benefit ends within 12 months after it starts and no later than the end of next year. A $1,200 annual software plan that starts December 20 and runs through December 19 qualifies. A two-year plan doesn't.
Bigger equipment follows its own rules, which the Section 179 and bonus depreciation guide covers. Items you place in service before December 31 are the ones that count for this year.
Keep the proof. Save the card statement or receipt that shows the charge date, and for a prepaid plan, save the invoice that shows the start and end dates. If the IRS ever asks, those dates decide whether the 12-month rule applies.
4.Moving Income Only Helps in Some Years
Delaying income sounds like a way to pay less tax. Take the $5,000 payment from the top of this post, and say you're in the 24% federal bracket. Self-employment tax is the 15.3% Social Security and Medicare you pay on top of income tax, and it applies to 92.35% of your profit, so it adds about 14.1%. That's 38.1% in total.
On $5,000, that's $1,905. If the payment lands in January, you owe the $1,905 a year later, on next year's return. You kept the money for a year, and that's the only gain, unless next year's rate is lower.
Judge Learned Hand wrote the line courts still cite on this in Helvering v. Gregory (2d Cir. 1934): "Any one may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which will best pay the Treasury." Choosing which December or January day a payment arrives is exactly that kind of arranging, as long as the dates you report are the real ones.
Now flip the example. Say a bigger year pushes that same $5,000 into the 32% federal bracket. The tax on it is about $2,305 (32% plus 14.1% is 46.1%), which is $400 more than the $1,905 it costs this year.
Moving a payment across December 31 changes when you pay the tax, and it changes how much only if your rate changes.
Look at next year before you defer anything. If you expect a bigger year, with a new retainer or a raise from a steady client, a payment taxed in the lower bracket this year beats one taxed in the higher bracket next year. In that case, ask clients to pay before the thirty-first.
5.A 20-Minute Check in December
One short check is enough, and it fits in an evening. Sit down once in the second week of December with your bank account and your open invoices, and go through these:
- Money already received: add up everything that landed or arrived in your mailbox this year, including deposits for work that starts in January.
- Open invoices: list each one with its due date. Decide which you want paid before the thirty-first and which can wait.
- Planned purchases: pick the equipment or subscriptions you'd buy in January anyway, and charge them in December if next year's rate is the same or lower.
- Prepayable costs: check whether any annual plan qualifies for the 12-month rule.
- Next year's guess: write down a rough income number so you know whether to pull income forward or push it out.
A freelancer who never invoices late and never charges a purchase early still pays the correct tax. Over a lifetime of returns, the December timing you choose mostly shifts money between two years, so a few hours of effort is plenty and a few days is too many. The December check only changes which return a payment goes on. The unpaid invoice deduction post covers the other side of the cash method: money you never received isn't income, so you have nothing to write off.
If you want to see what your own number looks like before the year ends, the free checkup at simplance.org/tax-checkup takes a few minutes.
Discussion
0 comments
Sign in to join the conversation
Loading comments...